Diberdayakan oleh Blogger.

Popular Posts Today

Op-Ed Columnist: Is Glenn Greenwald the Future of News?

Written By Unknown on Senin, 28 Oktober 2013 | 13.25

Much of the speculation about the future of news focuses on the business model: How will we generate the revenues to pay the people who gather and disseminate the news? But the disruptive power of the Internet raises other profound questions about what journalism is becoming, about its essential character and values. This week's column is a conversation — a (mostly) civil argument — between two very different views of how journalism fulfills its mission.

Glenn Greenwald broke what is probably the year's biggest news story, Edward Snowden's revelations of the vast surveillance apparatus constructed by the National Security Agency. He has also been an outspoken critic of the kind of journalism practiced at places like The New York Times, and an advocate of a more activist, more partisan kind of journalism. Earlier this month he announced he was joining a new journalistic venture, backed by eBay billionaire Pierre Omidyar, who has promised to invest $250 million and to "throw out all the old rules." I invited Greenwald to join me in an online exchange about what, exactly, that means.

Dear Glenn,

We come at journalism from different traditions. I've spent a life working at newspapers that put a premium on aggressive but impartial reporting, that expect reporters and editors to keep their opinions to themselves unless they relocate (as I have done) to the pages clearly identified as the home of opinion. You come from a more activist tradition — first as a lawyer, then as a blogger and columnist, and soon as part of a new, independent journalistic venture financed by the eBay founder Pierre Omidyar. Your writing proceeds from a clearly stated point of view.

In a post on Reuters this summer, media critic Jack Shafer celebrated the tradition of partisan journalism — "From Tom Paine to Glenn Greenwald" — and contrasted it with what he called "the corporatist ideal." He didn't explain the phrase, but I don't think he meant it in a nice way. Henry Farrell, who blogs for The Washington Post, wrote more recently that publications like The New York Times and The Guardian "have political relationships with governments, which make them nervous about publishing (and hence validating) certain kinds of information," and he suggested that your new project with Omidyar would represent a welcome escape from such relationships.

I find much to admire in America's history of crusading journalists, from the pamphleteers to the muckrakers to the New Journalism of the '60s to the best of today's activist bloggers. At their best, their fortitude and passion have stimulated genuine reforms (often, as in the Progressive Era, thanks to the journalists' "political relationships with governments"). I hope the coverage you led of the National Security Agency's hyperactive surveillance will lead to some overdue accountability.

But the kind of journalism The Times and other mainstream news organizations practice — at their best — includes an awful lot to be proud of, too, revelations from Watergate to torture and secret prisons to the malfeasance of the financial industry, and including some pre-Snowden revelations about the N.S.A.'s abuse of its authority. Those are highlights that leap to mind, but you'll find examples in just about every day's report. Journalists in this tradition have plenty of opinions, but by setting them aside to follow the facts — as a judge in court is supposed to set aside prejudices to follow the law and the evidence — they can often produce results that are more substantial and more credible. The mainstream press has had its failures — episodes of credulousness, false equivalency, sensationalism and inattention — for which we have been deservedly flogged. I expect you'll say, not flogged enough. So I pass you the lash.

Dear Bill,

There's no question that journalists at establishment media venues, certainly including The New York Times, have produced some superb reporting over the last couple of decades. I don't think anyone contends that what has become (rather recently) the standard model for a reporter — concealing one's subjective perspectives or what appears to be "opinions" — precludes good journalism.

But this model has also produced lots of atrocious journalism and some toxic habits that are weakening the profession. A journalist who is petrified of appearing to express any opinions will often steer clear of declarative sentences about what is true, opting instead for a cowardly and unhelpful "here's-what-both-sides-say-and-I-won't-resolve-the-conflicts" formulation. That rewards dishonesty on the part of political and corporate officials who know they can rely on "objective" reporters to amplify their falsehoods without challenge (i.e., reporting is reduced to "X says Y" rather than "X says Y and that's false").

Worse still, this suffocating constraint on how reporters are permitted to express themselves produces a self-neutering form of journalism that becomes as ineffectual as it is boring. A failure to call torture "torture" because government officials demand that a more pleasant euphemism be used, or lazily equating a demonstrably true assertion with a demonstrably false one, drains journalism of its passion, vibrancy, vitality and soul.

Worst of all, this model rests on a false conceit. Human beings are not objectivity-driven machines. We all intrinsically perceive and process the world through subjective prisms. What is the value in pretending otherwise?


13.25 | 0 komentar | Read More

Editorial: ‘Not One More’

President Obama urged Congress on Thursday to revive immigration reform, which is not dead but not moving, either. He was talking mostly to House Republicans, though he also urged business, labor and religious groups to "keep putting the pressure on all of us to get this done."

It's good that Mr. Obama said "us." It acknowledges his own role in this continuing disaster.

Much of the responsibility to fix what Mr. Obama calls the "broken immigration system" lies within his own administration. He can't rewrite immigration laws, but he can control how well — or disastrously — they are enforced. He can begin by undoing the damage done by his Homeland Security Department. Mr. Obama has just nominated Jeh Johnson, a former Defense Department general counsel, to replace homeland security secretary Janet Napolitano, who resigned in July. It's the perfect opportunity for a fresh start. Here is what it might look like:

STOP NEEDLESS DEPORTATIONS The Obama administration has kept up a frantic pace of 400,000 deportations a year, and is closing in on two million. Those numbers are driven by politics, not public safety. Immigration and Customs Enforcement has wide discretion to determine whom it detains and deports. It can retool all its policies to make noncriminals and minor offenders — the people most likely to benefit from the reform now stalled in Congress — the lowest priority for deportation.

The deportation surge is fed by programs like Secure Communities, which does immigration checks on everyone arrested by local and state law enforcement, and Operation Streamline, in which border crossers in the Southwest are prosecuted en masse, with little access to legal representation. Mr. Obama turned the dragnet on, and can turn it off. In marches and vigils across the country, protesters have made one plea on deportations to Mr. Obama: "Not one more." He should heed it.

ACKNOWLEDGE THE CRISIS As he makes the case for immigration reform, Mr. Obama often mentions the economic consequences of failure — jobs unfilled, crops unpicked, investments not made and taxes not collected. He would do well to highlight the human costs of enforcement without reform, in separating families, and violating the civil and labor rights of workers.

Defiant advocates in Tucson, Ariz., recently blocked buses carrying Operation Streamline detainees, drawing attention to the damage done by indiscriminate deportation. In East Haven, Conn., last week, two police officers were convicted of abusing Latino residents, part of an egregious pattern of abuse. There and elsewhere, the Justice Department has done much to investigate and stop illegal policing and civil rights abuses; Mr. Obama should redouble administration efforts to protect the rights of immigrants and noncitizens.

GET BEYOND POLITICS The talk in Washington has focused on how, after the shutdown debacle, Republicans and Democrats might exploit immigration for political advantage. But last week, the genuine immigration crisis intruded, as if from another universe. Busloads of Arizonans — parents, children, students known as Dreamers — lined up outside House Speaker John Boehner's office, pleading for a meeting and praying for action on reform. Mr. Boehner had no time for them.

The shutdown was a fake emergency. Immigration is a real one, harming lives every day in every state. Mr. Obama has sometimes been resentful when immigrant advocates remind him of his failures. Now, at least, he has invited their pressure.


13.25 | 0 komentar | Read More

Editorial: Why Prisons Are Shrinking

The mandatory sentencing movement that swept the United States beginning in the 1970s drove the state prison population up from less than 200,000 to about 1.4 million today and made corrections the second-fastest-growing state expense after Medicaid. But bipartisan sentencing reforms in a growing number of states are starting to reverse that trend — causing the prison population to decline by about 3.8 percent since 2009.

Connect With Us on Twitter

For Op-Ed, follow @nytopinion and to hear from the editorial page editor, Andrew Rosenthal, follow @andyrNYT.

Underlying the state reforms is a relatively new and more sophisticated way of using data about the offender — including criminal history, drug abuse and instances of antisocial behavior — to assess the likelihood of that individual's committing a new crime. And by examining arrest, sentencing and probation data, the states can revise policies that might be driving people back into prison unnecessarily.

States have found that many inmates go back to prison not for committing new crimes but for technical violations, like missing appointments with parole officers or failing drug tests. With that knowledge, states have moved to less costly and more effective sanctions — a brief jail stay, community service or more frequent meetings with the parole officer — for such offenses.

Some states are also embracing what is known as the "justice reinvestment" approach, under which they channel significant sums of money into improved parole or probation services while beefing up the drug treatment and mental health services that many ex-offenders need to stay out of trouble.

Despite the merits of a risk-assessment approach, a report issued earlier this year by the Council of State Governments Justice Center said that many states are still flying blind, because they don't have the resources to gather data. Moreover, the study noted, handling high-risk and low-risk offenders in the same way is a big mistake, because "low risk individuals have an increased likelihood of recidivism when they are oversupervised or receive treatment or services in the same programs as medium- and high-risk individuals."

There are proven ways to move away from discredited, ruinously expensive corrections policies. More states need to adopt these approaches.


13.25 | 0 komentar | Read More

Editorial: For Extending New York’s Judicial Terms

The judicial retirement ages embedded in New York State's Constitution are a relic of a time when average life expectancy was much shorter than it is today. A sensible proposal on the Nov. 5 ballot, Proposition 6, would modestly extend the age limits for certain state judges and help ease court system backlogs by allowing seasoned judges to stay on past age 70. We urge voters to approve the change.

Connect With Us on Twitter

For Op-Ed, follow @nytopinion and to hear from the editorial page editor, Andrew Rosenthal, follow @andyrNYT.

Under the plan, members of New York's Supreme Court — comprising the state's primary trial court and the intermediate appellate court — would be eligible to serve up to five more two-year terms once they reach 70, allowing them to serve until age 80. Now, a State Supreme Court justice may serve three two-year terms beyond the age of 70, so the change would raise the cap by four years.

These five-term extensions would be subject to medical certification of continued fitness, just as the current three-term extensions are. In all, 28 judges would become eligible for the extra extensions in the next four years, according to court officials. This would give court administrators new flexibility to assign judges to family court and other areas where there is a pressing need.

Proposition 6 would also let members of the state's highest court, the Court of Appeals, serve past that court's current mandatory retirement age of 70. Just a few years ago, the state's former chief judge, Judith Kaye, one of the nation's most able jurists, was forced to step down because of that rule for no good reason. Under the ballot proposal, Court of Appeals judges would be allowed to serve out any 14-year term on the court begun before they reach age 70, subject to a requirement that they step off the bench by the last day of the year in which they turn 80. Judge Kaye's successor, Jonathan Lippman, for example, would be allowed to stay on the court until his term ended in early 2023, at age 77. For reasons of continuity, fairness and judicial independence, the reform is overdue.


13.25 | 0 komentar | Read More

Editorial | The City Life: A Real Job in Make-Believe

It's called "faking New York" — making a movie or television show in some other city with locales ginned up to resemble the one and only. "A lot of people were faking New York," says Katherine Oliver, the commissioner of the Mayor's Office of Media and Entertainment, looking back over the last 11 years. "They were making a movie about Rudy Giuliani in Montreal! Ridiculous."

Connect With Us on Twitter

For Op-Ed, follow @nytopinion and to hear from the editorial page editor, Andrew Rosenthal, follow @andyrNYT.

Things have turned around, as any New Yorker could see in checking out the production caravan parked last month on Riverside Drive, where the cast and crew of "The Good Wife" was, as usual, faking Chicago. In the current TV season, 26 prime-time series used locations in the city, versus seven a decade ago.

The industry accounts for an estimated $7.1 billion in direct spending in the city a year, employing more than 130,000 people. At the entry level are production assistants, running errands and holding up pedestrians. A case in point is Jessica Mayfield, who got her chance as a production assistant after graduating from the five-week "Made in NY" course designed by the city's media office and the nonprofit Brooklyn Workforce Innovations. She is a 27-year-old Manhattan native who needed a job three years ago and stumbled onto a career track while pausing at a film location. "I'm lucky," she says of being promoted from her boot-camp start to her latest job as a producer's aide specializing in actors' contracts.

New Yorkers complain about inconvenience, particularly when prime parking spots are taken over by film crew caravans. But Ms. Mayfield and the more than 400 production assistants who have gone through the program are the upside to all the klieg-lit commotion.


13.25 | 0 komentar | Read More

Editorial | Notebook: The A Train to Autumn

Written By Unknown on Minggu, 27 Oktober 2013 | 13.25

Byron Smith for The New York Times

A 4 train headed toward Van Cortlandt Park in the Bronx offers great fall views, as do the other subway lines with elevated tracks.

Leaf-watching season in the Northeast is dazzling but fleeting. If you haven't already taken Amtrak's Adirondack train, with its special glass-domed car, up the Hudson Valley and beyond to see forested riverbanks in their coats of many, many colors, you've pretty much missed that chance — the leaves have peaked, and dome car service ends Tuesday.

But if you're in New York City, you don't have to go far — not even to Yonkers — to see leaves that haven't peaked. Get yourself a MetroCard, a cup of coffee and a smartphone with a tree-identification app. And stand clear of the closing doors, please.

From mid-Manhattan, take an outbound train. It could be the A, the 7, the 1, the 4 or the Long Island Rail Road to Jamaica. As long as the line ends up above ground beyond Manhattan (very important), it almost doesn't matter.

Take the A, for instance. It climbs into daylight near Liberty Avenue in Queens on its way to Jamaica Bay and the Rockaways. You see row houses and scrubby street trees — this is definitely not Vermont. But tune out the concrete, brick and asphalt, and soon you won't see the city for the trees: lush, brazen, almost incandescent in the morning sunlight. Over by Aqueduct Racetrack, vines and a dense tree canopy appear to be devouring the platform: green vengeance, soon to turn crimson, ocher, gold.

On the other side of Queens, on the elevated 7 line, the World's Fair grounds form an ample urban woodland. After you cross the verdant Grand Central Parkway (thank you, Robert Moses), turn your back on Citi Field and look south upon the meadows of Flushing. The express inches through a copse of trees, then over the Flushing River, with its old pilings and mud at low tide, and a pair of bonus ducks. You have already seen more leaves than you would have ever expected, from the subway.

But the best is yet to come. On the 4, up and beyond the East Side, past Yankee Stadium and the Kingsbridge Armory, among the brick apartment blocks and rocky outcroppings: stands of stubborn ailanthus and oak, subway platforms choked in blush-red ivy.

The end of the line is a forest: Van Cortlandt Park, one of the city's largest, next to Woodlawn Cemetery, the leafy permanent address of Herman Melville, Miles Davis and Fiorello La Guardia.

Head out of the turnstiles, go up the block, onto a wooded path. Signs tell you of Norway maple, pin oak, sweet gum. And poison ivy, now lustrous red and yellow.

Heading back toward the subway, you pass two workers in helmets and orange vests talking park business. Heedless of trail etiquette, they walk by without a nod, not even looking up. This may be the woods, but it is still the Bronx.


13.25 | 0 komentar | Read More

Opinion: Riding Out Sandy in the Rockaways

Jonah Markowitz

Life after Sandy. James Culleton prepares for a day of fishing aboard his boat, the Easy Rider, in Howard Beach, Brooklyn, in the summer of 2013.

WHEN the morning tide came in you could tell it was going to be a big one. I live in Arverne, a neighborhood in the Rockaways, and in the morning when I was walking up Thursby Avenue I could already see the water coming in on that first tide.

But no one was really panicking yet. We get flooding from time to time. But the wind hadn't even started blowing yet and already the water was coming down the road.

That's when I see these two swans. They're just as happy as can be floating down the middle of the road. The water went around the corner and the swans went that way too. I wonder what happened to them.

Come nighttime, the wind's really starting to blow. I didn't really think about evacuating. My idea — I was going to sit in my boat and ride it out like a Viking. I've been in hurricanes before.

Anyway, during the day I caught a load of fish 'cause, you know, when a big storm's coming you better have something on hand that you can sell afterward.

Around 7 p.m. I get in my truck. Suddenly I see a huge wave coming down the road. I turn down another road and there's an electrical wire in the water, sparking, so I go up the next street.

I turn around and see a friend of mine on the porch of his house and I say, "Hey, Mike, you need a hand?"

He says, "Yeah, come on in, I could use some help."

We go down in the basement and start putting up all the electrical equipment. We take a break and watch a little TV, try to see what's happening on the Weather Channel. It doesn't sound too bad so far.

All of a sudden the basement window lets go and the water starts pouring in. The kids go flying up the stairs and we're following them.

I realize I gotta move my truck. I reach in my pocket and I remember my keys are downstairs under six feet of water. I can't get home.

Now all hell breaks loose. The wind's howling, the rain's cutting you like a knife in the face. And the wires are arcing and sparking on the side of the house.

Now here comes more water, pouring down the road. The funny thing is when floods come in and the cars go underwater, all the lights in the cars go on like something from "Voyage to the Bottom of the Sea" — all the car lights are on, the windshield wipers are going, the horns are blowing.

Jonah Markowitz

After being evicted from emergency housing, Mr. Culleton stayed with friends or slept in his truck outside the local police station.

I see the lights go on in my truck and I say to myself, "That's it."

Now the water's coming up the front steps and we tell the kids and the wife to go upstairs. We say, "Don't worry about it, it looks like the water's going down." The wife turns around and gives this knowing look.

Then the lights in the house go off. The place gets eerie. Like something out of a horror movie. The car lights underwater are the only thing you could see. You wonder, "What the hell's next?"

I'm thinking about my house with no basement down in the low area down by the bay — can't be much left of it. And then I'm thinking about my boat, my livelihood. Not knowing is worse than knowing.

We start smelling smoke and hearing popping noises. We look out the front window toward the east; that's where the wind's coming from. There's a fire coming and looks like it's whipping straight at you — sparks, flames shooting everywhere. We can't figure where anything is. It's just hell. I start calling 911 — that's a waste of time. Better off talking to your shoes. All you get is a recording.

Jonah Markowitz

Mr. Culleton takes a moment to rest at a single room occupancy residence in Rockaway Park.

I realize it's like being in your boat. No one's gonna help you.

So I said maybe we have to try to get the kids out and hopefully the fire don't come. You could see the shock in the wife's face. You could see it but she was hiding it to make the kids not be scared. They're upstairs playing with their Transformer toys.

And the water keeps coming and I'm thinking about the people down south during Hurricane Katrina — how they got caught in their attics and drowned. I think we might need to cut a hole in the roof. We got a cordless saw. But we got no power.

And that's when I look out the window and I see the water joining up — the bay is hooking up with the ocean. The water's all around. It's just like being on a boat at sea. We go upstairs. And finally the water starts going down and we collapse.

The next morning we wake up. Everybody's walking around like zombies. It's not just the loss of property, it's the mental trauma. The unknowing of the future. We go outside and it's a new world. Stuff everywhere. All five blocks around us burned to the ground.

I end up staying at Mike's for two weeks — that's how long it takes me to get my house keys back from the bottom of the basement.

Around that time Mike's next-door neighbor, the only one with a working car, he goes down to the boat yard. And he says, "Hey, I seen your boat. Your boat made it." So I go back home. And I see my boat, the Easy Rider. It made it through O.K.

But my yard's so full of garbage I can't get in the front door of my house. I climb over the neighbor's fence. I see all my equipment is wiped out. I open the other door and a busted pipe blasts me in the face with water. I turn the water off, nail the front door shut and say: "The hell with this place. I gotta get my sanity back."

I been working on fixing the house for a year now. I still can't go home.

James Culleton is a fisherman based in the Rockaways. This account was told to Paul Greenberg, the author of "Four Fish" and the forthcoming "American Catch."


13.25 | 0 komentar | Read More

News Analysis: Nothing Personal: They Want to Eat You

ZOMBIES may be hogging the pop culture spotlight these days in "World War Z" and "The Walking Dead," but now that the flesh-eating undead are selling Sprint cellphones in television ads, one has to wonder: have they finally jumped the shark as the monster of the moment?

Well, there's a new wave of evildoers waiting to step in: cannibals.

At the Toronto International Film Festival in September, Eli Roth's hungry-savages film, "The Green Inferno," and Manuel Martín Cuenca's dark love story "Cannibal" played to gore-loving crowds. Other releases this fall include "Butcher Boys," an urban thriller based on Jonathan Swift's satirical 18th-century essay "A Modest Proposal"; "The Colony," about flesh-eating survivors of an apocalyptic attack; "We Are What We Are," about a father and his cannibal children; the German-language "Cannibal Diner," with young women on the menu; and "Evil Feed," a comedy about a restaurant that serves the body parts of losing participants in an underground fighting ring.

On the small screen, NBC's crime drama "Hannibal," based on Thomas Harris's notorious flesh muncher Hannibal Lecter, will return for a second season. And two plays (both closing this weekend) brought cannibalism to the stage: In New York, "feeling" told the story of a woman who talks with Jeffrey Dahmer; in Minneapolis, "Kung Fu Zombies vs. Cannibals" took a comic-book approach to the subject.

So what's behind this burst of fascination with flesh eating?

For Mr. Roth, the director of "Hostel" and an expert on pushing the boundaries of horror, the fear of cannibals "is not just having your own flesh devoured, but that you would have a taste for another person's flesh. It's a primal feeling."

The tag line for "The Green Inferno," showing on Nov. 2 as part of the Film Society of Lincoln Center's Scary Movies series, is, "The only thing more terrifying than Mother Nature is human nature."

Gunnar Hansen, who played the weapon-wielding Leatherface in "The Texas Chainsaw Massacre" (1974), a pioneering foray into cannibalistic terrain, sees it as a sign of the times, just as the cold war gave rise to fever dreams of space invaders and Vietnam ushered in a modern zombie era with "Night of the Living Dead."

"You can look at the economy and say the past is about to bite us literally and figuratively," said Mr. Hansen, whose new memoir is called "Chain Saw Confidential." "We are at the point where a new generation has nothing to look forward to."

Or perhaps there's something more visceral at work. Another early favorite of horror cognoscenti — and an inspiration for Mr. Roth's "Green Inferno" — is Ruggero Deodato's "Cannibal Holocaust" (1980), about a documentary crew that's attacked by the flesh-eating tribe they are filming in the Amazon. Its depiction of real-life animal slaughter, which still shocks today, suggests a weird affinity with today's animal-rights' movement.

"People rarely think of steak or fried chicken as consuming a dead thing," said Tim Kelly, who writes about the cannibal genre for Cinematallica.com. "Cannibals force you to confront something you don't want to understand, which is the truth of what you are consuming."

Then again, maybe it was just a matter of time before pop culture caught up with real-life reports of cannibalism, like the case of a New York police officer who was convicted in March for a plot to kill and eat women.

And there's always the possibility of shock fatigue. "Ten years ago nobody would laugh at a movie about eating people," said Aaron Au, a co-writer of "Evil Feed." "But the zombie genre desensitized us to be accepting of it."

On another, even creepier, level, what sets cannibals apart from zombies may simply be their humanity. As Kimani Ray Smith, the director of "Evil Feed," put it: "A cannibal's just a smarter zombie. You need more cunning to get away with being a cannibal. But cannibals still have day-to-day problems. They still have to pay the rent."

Erik Piepenburg is an editor in the culture department of The New York Times.


13.25 | 0 komentar | Read More

Opinionator | The Great Divide: Division Street, U.S.A.

We don't talk much about "the wrong side of the tracks" in public anymore, but the distinction between one place and another is implicitly understood and often explicitly specified. That location matters greatly for housing values, for example, is taken for granted. Less appreciated is the persistence of neighborhood inequality and its extensive reach into multiple aspects of everyday life. An increasing separation at the top has intensified the effect of spatial divisions on everyone else.

Our understanding of the neighborhood as a consolidating feature of American inequality has roots in a classic tradition of scholarly research. The eminent sociologist William Julius Wilson brought the geographic isolation of poor urban blacks to public attention in 1987 in a book he famously called "The Truly Disadvantaged." A few years later, the sociologists Douglas Massey and Nancy Denton underscored the profound separation of blacks and whites by neighborhood.

Although much has improved in the inner city since then, it is still common in American cities to find neighborhoods struggling with poverty rates well above the national average, sometimes just streets away from neighborhoods brimming with affluence. While racial segregation has modestly declined in recent decades, the latest data reveal that approximately 60 percent of blacks or whites in metropolitan areas across the United States would have to relocate to achieve racial integration. In New York City, an eye-popping 81 percent of whites or blacks would have to move.

Fifty years after the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. pointed to African-Americans on a "lonely island of poverty in the midst of a vast ocean of material prosperity," racial and economic disparities by place not only remain but are closely connected. Nationwide, close to a third of African-American children born between 1985 and 2000 were raised in high-poverty neighborhoods compared with just 1 percent of whites. Crucially, income does not erase place-based racial inequality — affluent blacks typically live in poorer neighborhoods than the average lower-income white resident.

The stigmatization and widespread social exclusion of poor neighborhoods is corrosive.

The great neighborhood divide extends to many of the fundamentals of well-being. Violence, poor physical health, teenage pregnancy, obesity, fear and dropping out of school are all unequally distributed. Getting ahead economically is also shaped by where you live, even more than you might think. Despite the effects of globalization and the rise of technologies that allow us to work or interact virtually anywhere, the economist Raj Chetty and colleagues found that upward mobility — the odds of a child raised in the bottom fifth of income rising to the top fifth as an adult — is lower for those who grew up in cities characterized by racially and economic segregated neighborhoods.

What many have come to call "mass incarceration" has a local face as well — only a small proportion of communities have experienced America's prisoner boom whereas others are relatively untouched. I was taken aback to learn that the highest incarceration rate among African-American communities in Chicago was over 40 times higher than the highest ranked white community. This is a staggering difference of kind, not degree. And it does not go unnoticed, even by children. In one neighborhood I came across a wall behind a school with sketches of the grim faces of black men behind prison bars. An open book and diploma were drawn underneath — hope to be sure, but against a backdrop of despair.

The stigmatization and widespread social exclusion of poor neighborhoods is corrosive. Cynicism toward institutions is high despite the commitment of residents to conventional values. In Chicago, for example, lower income and minority residents are more likely to condemn smoking, drinking and fighting among teenagers than upper class or white residents. Yet concentrated poverty lowered perceived trust and social cohesion among fellow residents, reinforcing a negative feedback loop.

Even the simple act of mailing a lost letter you find lying in the street varies greatly. As part of our larger project, a team at the Institute of Social Research conducted a field experiment to determine the rate at which strangers mailed back over 3,000 stamped letters randomly dropped in the streets of Chicago. The rate of return by neighborhood ranged from zero to over 75 percent. After adjusting for things like weather conditions, land use and housing patterns, concentrated poverty predicted lower rates of return.

Less visible are the long-term consequences of growing up in concentrated poverty for human capital development. In Chicago we found that early exposure to severely disadvantaged communities was associated with diminished verbal skills later in childhood. We estimated that living in concentrated disadvantage depressed the rate of future verbal learning by about four I.Q. points, akin to missing a year of school.

An experiment begun in the mid-1990s by the Department of Housing and Urban Development looked at a similar issue in a different way. Housing vouchers were randomly assigned to poor families that could be redeemed only by moving to a lower poverty neighborhood. Even though final destinations were just marginally better, poor children whose families moved out of the most severely disadvantaged neighborhoods in Baltimore and Chicago showed the largest improvements in cognitive skills. These cities have concentrated poverty, racial segregation and violent crime rates higher than those of Boston, New York or Los Angeles, the other project sites. In other words, in cities with more desperate pockets of isolation, the move was more advantageous.

Neighborhood disadvantage can extend across surprisingly long periods of time in the lives of children and families. My colleagues and I just completed a long-term follow-up of over 1,000 children from the study in Chicago that we began in 1995. We tracked a birth cohort, 9-, 12-, and 15-year-olds, no matter where they moved in the United States. Among the near-majority of black infants born in high poverty neighborhoods in 1995, more than half remained there in 2012; 13 percent had "moved up" to low poverty.

What about downward mobility? Over a third of black infants born in low poverty ended up in high poverty neighborhoods, compared with 2 percent of white children.

The results for adolescents show even greater inequality by race: almost 70 percent of black adolescents raised in concentrated poverty areas remain there as young adults; 55 percent of the small group raised in low poverty nonetheless ended up in high poverty. Again the contrasts are striking: almost no adolescent whites experience concentrated poverty in the first place, and for the majority who were raised in low poverty, only 9 percent were downwardly mobile 17 years later.

The extent of intergenerational transmission of neighborhood disadvantage is also notable. A study by Patrick Sharkey of N.Y.U. found that approximately half of black families in the United States had lived in the poorest quarter of neighborhoods in consecutive generations since the 1970s, compared with only 7 percent of white families.

These durable inequalities seem paradoxical when we consider the changing American landscape.

Inequality may persist in the lives of individuals, but what about neighborhoods themselves? Do the same neighborhoods remain poor decade after decade, or is poverty "reshuffled"? And what about gentrification?

Although there is always population turnover of individual residents and fluctuations in the poverty rate over time, it turns out that if we know where a neighborhood starts out statistically, we can do rather well predicting where it will end up relative to other neighborhoods. Many poor neighborhoods get stuck for decades.

The "stickiness" of inequality by place is also notable at the high end. The Gold Coast of Chicago is as golden as ever, and elite neighborhoods from the Upper East Side of New York to Bel-Air in Los Angeles are in no danger of even relative decline.

These durable inequalities seem paradoxical when we consider the changing American landscape. Poverty is increasing most rapidly in the suburbs, crime has decreased just about everywhere, and gentrification is reshaping many working-class and poor areas of central cities. New York is the poster child these days for crime reduction and a new type of urban renewal. The media has focused attention on Brooklyn, for example, highlighting neighborhoods undergoing gentrification that were in despair not long ago.

The phenomenon is real but the fact that it makes the news is precisely the point — "rags to riches" is no more common among neighborhoods than it is among people. For every poor neighborhood on the move, more struggle out of the media glare. And while large cities like Detroit have been much in the news for spectacular failure, smaller cities and towns like Flint, Mich., and Port Clinton, Ohio, contain some of America's poorest and hardest-hit neighborhoods.

Unfortunately, many social policies tend to accentuate these trends rather than mitigate them. The persistent geography of inequality is reinforced by exclusionary zoning, persistent red lining, selective withdrawal of public services, the segregation of low-income public housing, "stop and frisk" policing concentrated in minority areas, school funding tied to property values and the political fragmentation of metropolitan areas. The city line is more than just geography, it typically means a sharp social boundary.

The good news is that we are experimenting with a number of policies, some place-based and others person-based. Both are needed, but in either case the durability of poverty calls for profound long-term investments. Although funding levels are still too low relative to the magnitude of the challenge, sustained investment in disadvantaged communities is at the core of the Obama administration's "Promise Zones" initiative, modeled in part after Geoffrey Canada's Harlem Children's Zone. There are also some encouraging results from a long-term effort to develop mixed-income housing in suburban Mount Laurel, N.J. In addition to promoting quality early childhood education and affordable housing, reducing violence must be central to any community intervention.

There is no magic bullet, however, and historical trends caution against quick solutions. In a kind of self-fulfilling prophecy, neighborhoods have an effect on people's lives in part because people and institutions act as if neighborhoods matter, further reinforcing the reproduction of inequality by place. Crime, perceived safety and the quality of local schools lead to reputations that have real consequences. Neighborhood reputations may well be sturdier than those of individuals, a point not lost on real estate agents.

The tendency of humans to segregate by place has also persisted across long time spans and eras despite the transformation of specific boundaries, political regimes and the layout of cities. Research by archaeologists indicates that spatial divisions like ours were found in ancient cities, too.

The greatest divisions of place today are at the very top, creating what we might call the new 1 percent neighborhoods. In recent decades, cities have been pulling apart; income inequality by neighborhood has increased. As a consequence, the kinds of mixed-income neighborhoods many of us remember from growing up have grown rarer, while exclusively affluent and exclusively poor neighborhoods have grown much more common.

The Great Recession has exacerbated this divergence. Just as they have been among individuals, economic hardships have been unequally shared by neighborhoods: poverty, vacancy rates and particularly unemployment rates increased at a greater clip in disadvantaged and minority neighborhoods from 2005 to 2011 than elsewhere.

We live in a free society, of course, but the high-end spatial concentration of income and its associated resources, like well-endowed schools, security, abundant services and political connections, in effect pulls up the drawbridge from our neighbors. The hypersegregation of "the truly advantaged" speaks volumes about the continuing significance of place and raises important questions about what kind of society we want to be.


Robert J. Sampson is a professor of the social sciences at Harvard and the author of "Great American City: Chicago and the Enduring Neighborhood Effect."


13.25 | 0 komentar | Read More

Editorial: Bill de Blasio for Mayor

The rise of Bill de Blasio, New York City's public advocate, has been remarkable. In a clamorous primary campaign against better known, more seasoned candidates, he won the Democratic nomination without a runoff, by appealing directly and doggedly to struggling New Yorkers who see a city of lofty wealth rising out of their reach. With the election only 10 days away, Mr. de Blasio is polling so far ahead of the Republican, Joseph Lhota, that commentators have already anointed him leader of a national rebirth of left-wing populism.

Hold on. We're electing a mayor here, someone to keep streets plowed and safe, budgets balanced, schools working well and constituents of five boroughs satisfied. Someone to sustain and build on the 12-year legacy of Michael Bloomberg, while realizing his own vision for New York. It's a huge job, never mind the revolution.

Luckily, Mr. de Blasio is up for it.

During the Democratic primary scramble, the largest and most rancorous in decades, we gave our endorsement to Christine Quinn, citing her record as the City Council speaker. But it was Mr. de Blasio who proved far better at connecting with voters — and at being a persuasive advocate for his ideas. The ideas are good ones: Mr. de Blasio is right on public safety, and on the need to rein in the Police Department's unconstitutional use of stop-and-frisk tactics and restore its frayed ties to the community. He is right about the crisis of affordable housing, and he has the most comprehensive plan to attack it. His goal of expanding access to preschool education is a noble priority for the city. 

And he is giving a voice to the forgotten New Yorkers — the 46 percent living in or near poverty, the 50,000 living in homeless shelters, the millions living outside the zones of economic security and gentrified affluence. The city has had many successes in the Bloomberg years, but its rebirth is incomplete.

Public advocate is in many ways a negligible job, but Mr. de Blasio has used its bully pulpit well, to push for progress on affordable housing, health care and other issues, raising their profile (and, not accidentally, his own). His résumé — as regional housing official for President Bill Clinton, manager of Hillary Rodham Clinton's first Senate campaign, eight-year member of the City Council — has been called scant preparation to run an enterprise of 300,000 employees and a $70 billion budget. But Mr. Bloomberg also had limited government experience; he learned on the job, filled his administration with highly capable professionals, and became an effective mayor.

We're confident Mr. de Blasio can do the same, as he will have to, and quickly. There will be budget holes to fill and deals to strike with dozens of testy municipal unions. He has made ambitious promises to begin creating 200,000 units of affordable housing and to extend citywide full-day prekindergarten and after-school programs for middle schoolers.

Mr. Lhota says this plan, which requires raising taxes on rich people, will be dead on arrival in Albany, and he is probably right. But Mr. de Blasio's goal of giving poor children a better start on life is worth the fight. Mr. de Blasio's plans for education reform — he is far more skeptical about charter schools than Mr. Lhota is — also deserve a hearing. Improving the schools for all children is a job that Mr. Bloomberg has left unfinished.

Mr. Lhota is an experienced, capable public servant who served the city well as a budget director and deputy mayor, and as head of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority. It has been disheartening to see the usually levelheaded Mr. Lhota basing his campaign on fear, apparently having concluded that he won't win on managerial competence. He released a terrifying ad warning that electing Mr. de Blasio would unleash the forces of '70s-era crime and chaos, all but promising the return of crack dens, squeegee men, race riots and Son of Sam. After decades of steadily plunging crime, it's a ludicrous claim. If crime rises — and it may well rise under any mayor — it will not be, as Mr. Lhota has implied, because Mayor de Blasio's N.Y.P.D. was off giving group therapy to biker gangs. 

On addressing climate change and building a resilient city, improving public health and creating a smarter transportation grid, there is much of the Bloomberg agenda that does not need reinventing. Mr. de Blasio surely recognizes this, and he has the political skills to advance the best ideas in ways that do not leave lots of people out of the conversation.

Mr. de Blasio seems to be a good listener, though our hearts sink when we see him listening too attentively to interest groups like anti-horse-carriage zealots and deep-pocketed taxi fleet owners. Mr. de Blasio, who surfed through the primaries on a wave of admiring press coverage, can seem rattled and resentful when he is attacked in debates. He should realize that jabs from Mr. Lhota are the tiniest foretaste of what's awaiting him, from belligerent Council members, skeptical reporters, defiant municipal unions and aggrieved city power brokers.

Mr. Lhota has it backward when he accuses Mr. de Blasio of waging a divisive "class warfare" campaign. For all his reliance on his well-worn "tale of two cities" metaphor, Mr. de Blasio has already united New York. Voters across the boroughs support him overwhelmingly. He promises to be a mayor who listens instead of scolds, who calms fears instead of inciting them. If he combines his populist touch with attentive, courageous leadership, he will have earned the city's support; he already has ours.


13.25 | 0 komentar | Read More
techieblogger.com Techie Blogger Techie Blogger